BookResorts™ is an independent travel network offering over 100,000 hotels worldwide.is an independent travel network.

Amara Cay Resort Islamorada, Florida
Book Now Or call, 24/7+1 (888) 605-1350
Rooms & Suites Dine & Drink Activities Gallery FAQs
Ready to book?Lowest online rate, free perks and upgrades.Book nowCall 24/7 · 888-605-1350
Hotel comparison guide

Amara Cay Resort vs Atlantic Bay Resort

Amara Cay Resort is a 4-star oceanfront resort in Islamorada with family-friendly rooms, a zero-entry pool, private sunning beach, and on-site dining — read this if you want an active Keys beach stay with water sports and restaurants. Atlantic Bay Resort is a 3-star waterfront hotel in Tavernier with a small set of individually decorated rooms and a private beach — read this if you want a quieter Upper Keys waterfront option with strong guest ratings.

Updated

Curved resort pool with palm trees and loungers at Amara Cay Resort

Amara Cay Resort

Oceanfront · Family-friendly · On-site restaurants & activities

Best for families and guests who want oceanfront dining, a zero-entry pool, water-sport rentals, and more on-site activities.

See rooms & suites
Atlantic Bay Resort, Tavernier, Florida

Atlantic Bay Resort

Waterfront · Small property · Strong guest rating

Best for travelers seeking a compact Tavernier waterfront hotel with easy access to boat tours, a marina, and a high guest-rating score.

Quick Verdict: Amara Cay Resort vs Atlantic Bay Resort

When Amara Cay Resort wins: choose Amara Cay if you want a larger resort experience — more rooms, multiple on-site dining venues (ReelCatch, Tiki Bar, Coastal Cup & Lounge), a zero-entry pool and private elevated sunning beach, resort amenities for families, and access to the Islamorada Resort Collection shuttle and Rum Runner water taxi.

When Atlantic Bay Resort wins: pick Atlantic Bay if you prefer a smaller, quieter waterfront property in Tavernier with direct marina/beach access, free bicycles on site, a single outdoor pool, and very high guest ratings for a compact stay.

Bottom line: Amara Cay is the fuller resort experience for families and activity-focused stays in Islamorada; Atlantic Bay is a simpler waterfront alternative in Tavernier if you want a smaller property and a strong guest score.

Call +1 (888) 605-1350Book Amara Cay Resort

Amara Cay Resort vs Atlantic Bay Resort – At a Glance

Side-by-side facts for Amara Cay Resort and Atlantic Bay Resort
CategoryAmara Cay ResortAtlantic Bay Resort
Overall vibeMid-size, family-friendly oceanfront resort with lively dining and activitiesSmall, quieter waterfront hotel with a marina/beach focus
LocationIslamorada — Mile Marker 80, Atlantic (ocean) sideTavernier — waterfront near Mangrove Marina
Size (rooms)110 rooms across 4 floors19 individually decorated guestrooms
Ages / policyAll-ages; primary guest must be 21+ to check in
PoolsZero-entry oceanfront pool with in-pool loungers; pool hours 8am–sunsetOne outdoor pool (listed)
Restaurants & barsReelCatch (breakfast & dinner), Tiki Bar (lunch & dinner), Coastal Cup & LoungeNot published
Spa / wellnessOoh la la at The Collection (spa services available; beach yoga & massages offered)Not published
Known forWater sports, private sunning beach, event/wedding venues, Rum Runner water taxi to sister resortsWaterfront location with marina access and nearby boat tours/snorkeling
Accessibility & front deskWheelchair-accessible rooms and paths; 24-hour front deskWheelchair accessible (may have limitations); front desk with limited hours (8 AM–8 PM)
Resort fee & inclusionsMandatory resort fee covers access to multiple collection properties, water toys, shuttle/water taxi access and enhanced Wi‑Fi (amount varies)Resort fee USD 22.50 per night (lists beach towels, breakfast, housekeeping, parking included)

A Look Inside Amara Cay Resort

Amara Cay Resort: rooms & suitesRooms & suitesAmara Cay Resort: pools & beachPools & beachAmara Cay Resort: diningDiningAmara Cay Resort: spa & wellnessSpa & wellness
See all photos →

Location: Islamorada vs Tavernier

Amara Cay Resort – Location

Amara Cay sits at Mile Marker 80 on Islamorada’s Atlantic side with direct oceanfront access and views toward Alligator Reef Lighthouse.

  • Oceanfront setting with a private elevated sunning beach and stairway for snorkeling access (not a sand swimming beach).
  • Close to local dive centers and attractions such as Bud n' Mary's (short walk) and Indian Key (boat access).
  • Complimentary Rum Runner water taxi and shuttle service to sister properties and local points of interest.

Best if you want full oceanfront access and easy resort-collection transfers around Islamorada.

Atlantic Bay Resort – Location

Atlantic Bay Resort is a waterfront Tavernier hotel near Mangrove Marina and local boat tour departure points.

  • Built on the water with marina access and water-sport options listed as nearby.
  • Within local distance of John Pennekamp Coral Reef State Park and other Upper Keys attractions (listed distances provided by supplier).
  • Front desk staffed during limited hours; preferred airport listed as Miami Intl. Airport (MIA).

Best if you want a compact waterfront base near marinas and boat tours in Tavernier.

Rooms: space and choices

Amara Cay Resort – Rooms

Amara Cay offers 110 rooms and 18 named room types including oceanfront suites and multiple-bed family suites.

  • Room types include oceanfront suites with lanais, multiple-bed family suites up to 6 guests, and standard rooms with partial ocean or courtyard views.
  • Elevator access to four floors; pet-friendly policy allows up to two dogs per room (fee applies).
  • Primary guest must be 21+ at check-in; standard incidental card authorization policies apply.

Choose Amara Cay for a wider range of room sizes and family-friendly suites.

Atlantic Bay Resort – Rooms

Atlantic Bay has 19 individually decorated guestrooms in a smaller-property layout.

  • Room types listed include suites, cottages, deluxe rooms and bay-view options, some with kitchens.
  • Many rooms offer kitchenettes or full kitchens, useful for longer stays or light self-catering.
  • Housekeeping provided daily; free Wi‑Fi across the property.

Choose Atlantic Bay if you prefer a smaller, apartment-style or suite-focused stay with kitchen options.

Dining & drinks: on-site options

Amara Cay Resort – Dining & drinks

Amara Cay runs multiple on-site dining venues and a lobby bar, open to the public.

  • ReelCatch serves breakfast and dinner (hours published); Tiki Bar serves lunch and dinner and has poolside service.
  • Coastal Cup & Lounge provides lobby bar service and a daily happy hour 4–6pm.
  • Many dining venues welcome non-guests and accept reservations; complimentary parking is available for diners.

Amara Cay offers more on-property dining variety and scheduled live-music nights.

Atlantic Bay Resort – Dining & drinks

Atlantic Bay's supplier listing does not publish on-site signature restaurants or bar names.

  • Listing highlights room service is available.
  • Guests can use nearby marinas and local Tavernier dining options (not listed in supplier facts).
  • Complimentary Wi‑Fi is available for guests; meal specifics are not published in the supplier data.

Atlantic Bay is a simpler stay — expect fewer on-site dining venues and rely more on nearby restaurants or in-room kitchens.

Pools, beach & signature amenity

Amara Cay Resort – Pools, beach & signature amenity

Amara Cay centers its guest experience around a zero-entry oceanfront pool and a private elevated sunning beach with water access.

  • Zero-entry pool has in-pool loungers and runs 8am–sunset.
  • Private Lighthouse Beach supplies loungers, thatched huts, towels, and stair access for snorkeling (not a traditional sand swim beach).
  • Water-sport rentals (kayaks, paddleboards) and guided ecotours are offered.

Amara Cay is centered on waterfront pool/beach activities and easy access to snorkeling and water sports.

Atlantic Bay Resort – Pools, beach & signature amenity

Atlantic Bay provides waterfront access and lists a private beach and one outdoor pool.

  • Property highlights a private beach area and marina on site.
  • Outdoor pool is available and beach towels are provided.
  • Many water-based activities (snorkeling, scuba diving, fishing) are listed as nearby or on site.

Atlantic Bay is a compact waterfront option focused on marina and beach access rather than multiple resort pools or venues.

Wellness & nightlife

Amara Cay Resort – Wellness & nightlife

Amara Cay offers spa and wellness experiences through Ooh la la at The Collection and has scheduled live music at dining venues.

  • Spa menu includes massages, facials and salon services; beach yoga and on-site massages are offered as resort experiences.
  • Live music Thursday–Saturday at ReelCatch and Tiki Bar (6–9pm).
  • Fitness center open daily (6am–10pm).

Expect a full-service wellness offering plus evening live-music options at the resort.

Atlantic Bay Resort – Wellness & nightlife

Atlantic Bay's supplier listing does not publish an on-site spa or dedicated wellness center.

  • Guest rooms include in-room amenities and daily housekeeping; organized wellness offerings are not listed.
  • Nearby marinas and boat-based excursions are the primary activity options after hours.
  • Front desk is staffed limited hours, which can affect arranging late-night activities or wellness bookings.

Atlantic Bay is better suited to quiet waterfront stays and DIY wellness rather than resort spa programming.

Who Wins? Best Pick by Travel Style

Best for families & activities
Reception desk and wood-paneled wall with Amara Cay Resort lettering

Amara Cay Resort

Amara Cay — more rooms and family suites, kids-friendly dining deals, zero-entry pool, and a range of on-site water sports and activities.

Best compact waterfront stay
Atlantic Bay Resort, Tavernier, Florida

Atlantic Bay Resort

Atlantic Bay — a smaller Tavernier property with marina access, kitchen-equipped rooms, and a strong guest-rating for simple waterfront stays.

Best on-site dining & nightlife
Seating area in the resort lobby with wicker chairs and pendant lights

Amara Cay Resort

Amara Cay — multiple restaurants and bars (ReelCatch, Tiki Bar, Coastal Cup & Lounge) with live music and daily happy hours.

Best for self-catering / kitchen rooms
Atlantic Bay Resort, Tavernier, Florida

Atlantic Bay Resort

Atlantic Bay — many room types list kitchens or kitchenettes, handy for longer stays or light meal prep.

Frequently asked questions

Amara Cay Resort vs Atlantic Bay Resort: FAQs

See all FAQs →
Which hotel is better for families with children?

Amara Cay — it is explicitly family-friendly, has larger family suites, kids-eat-free night at ReelCatch, and a zero-entry pool suitable for children.

Which property has more on-site dining and evening activity?

Amara Cay — it runs ReelCatch, a poolside Tiki Bar, and a lobby lounge with scheduled live music and daily happy hour; Atlantic Bay does not publish similar on-site venues.

Do either of these properties offer kitchens in rooms?

Atlantic Bay lists several room types with kitchens or kitchenettes (Cottage, Suite Kitchen options). Amara Cay focuses on standard rooms and suites; kitchen-equipped rooms are not listed.

Which is better if I want to book boat tours or go diving?

Both properties are convenient for water activities: Amara Cay lists on-site snorkeling/diving options and close dive centers in Islamorada; Atlantic Bay lists boat tours, a marina on site, and scuba/snorkeling nearby in Tavernier.

More Amara Cay Resort Comparison Guides

Explore how Amara Cay Resort stacks up against other hotels nearby:

Couple enjoying a covered beachfront cabana looking toward the ocean at Amara Cay Resort
Book your stay

Oceanfront rooms with water‑sports access

  • Lowest rate guarantee
  • Complimentary perks & upgrades
  • 24/7 concierge
Check availability Call 888-605-1350
Offer terms

Price comparison & offer terms

These terms apply to the price comparison, Lowest Price Guarantee, free perks and concierge service shown on this site.

How we compare rates

The nightly rate shown is the lowest nightly rate we found for Amara Cay Resort after searching every available night up to 12 months in advance, based on single occupancy (one guest). We compared that rate with publicly available rates on other online travel agencies (OTAs), such as Expedia, Hotels.com and similar sites, and show the price difference we found. We don't name the specific site each comparison came from.

Rates and availability change constantly. The rate for your dates, room type and number of guests may be different. The full price, including taxes and fees, is shown before you confirm.

Lowest Price Guarantee

Free perks & upgrades

24/7 concierge

General

BookResorts may change or end these offers at any time. These terms are in addition to our Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy. BookResorts is an independent travel agency and is not affiliated with Amara Cay Resort.
Legal

Terms & Conditions

Last updated: January 1, 2026

Please read these Terms carefully. They contain important information about limitations of our liability and the resolution of disputes through binding arbitration and a class action waiver (Section 16), and our right to change these Terms (Section 18).

1. Acceptance of these terms

These Terms & Conditions (the “Terms”) govern your access to and use of BookResorts and any booking you make through us. By using the site or making a reservation, you agree to these Terms. If you do not agree, please do not use the site.

2. Definitions

“We,” “us,” and “our” refer to BookResorts, operated by SVH Tours & Travel Services, Inc. “You” refers to the person using the site or making a reservation. A “Supplier” or “Travel Provider” is the hotel, resort, or other provider that supplies the travel services. “Travel Services” means the room stays and related services made available through us. “Content” means text, descriptions, images, reviews, and other material on the site.

3. Who we are

BookResorts is an independent online travel agency that acts as an intermediary between you and Suppliers. We are not a hotel, and we are not owned by, affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by any hotel or brand featured on the site. When you book, your reservation is made with the Supplier through us as agent.

4. Eligibility & use of the site

You must be at least 18 years old (or the age of majority where you live) and able to enter a binding contract. You agree to use the site only to make legitimate reservations for yourself or for someone you are authorized to act for, to provide accurate and complete information, and to inform any other traveler of the terms that apply to their reservation.

5. Bookings & confirmation

All reservations are subject to availability and to the rate rules, restrictions, and policies shown at the time of booking. A reservation is confirmed only when you receive a confirmation from us. You are responsible for reviewing the rate rules (including cancellation terms) before you book.

6. Prices, fees, taxes & currency

Prices are shown in the currency indicated and include applicable taxes and fees unless stated otherwise; the total is displayed before you confirm. Our price may include a service fee and may differ from the rate offered directly by the Supplier. Currency conversions, where shown, are estimates. Certain taxes or resort fees may be collected by the Supplier at the property.

7. Cancellations, changes & refunds

Each rate carries its own cancellation policy, shown before you book (for example, non-refundable, or refundable up to a stated deadline). Refund eligibility and timing follow the policy attached to the rate you select. Service fees may be non-refundable. Failure to check in (“no-show”) may result in forfeiture of the amount paid, per the rate rules.

8. Your responsibilities

You are responsible for having valid identification and any required travel documents (such as a passport or visa), and for complying with the Supplier’s policies, including minimum check-in age, occupancy limits, deposits, and identification requirements. You are responsible for the accuracy of all guest information you provide.

9. Suppliers & third-party services

Suppliers are independent third parties. We are not liable for the acts, errors, omissions, representations, warranties, or negligence of any Supplier, or for the quality, condition, or safety of the travel services they provide. Any dispute regarding your stay or the services delivered is between you and the Supplier. Supplier terms and policies apply in addition to these Terms.

10. Third-party links

The site may contain links to third-party websites provided for your convenience. We do not control and are not responsible for those sites, and a link does not imply endorsement. Your use of any linked site is at your own risk and subject to that site’s terms.

11. Intellectual property

The site and its Content (excluding third-party trademarks) are owned by BookResorts or its licensors and are protected by law. Hotel names, logos, and trademarks are the property of their respective owners and are used only to identify the property being booked. You may not copy, scrape, or reuse any Content without permission.

12. Prohibited conduct

You agree not to use the site for any unlawful or fraudulent purpose; not to make speculative, false, or fraudulent reservations; not to use automated tools to access or scrape the site; and not to interfere with the site’s operation or security.

13. Reviews & user content

If you submit reviews or other content, you grant us a non-exclusive, royalty-free license to use, display, and distribute it in connection with our services. You are responsible for what you submit, and we may remove content at our discretion.

14. Disclaimers

The site, its Content, and the travel services are provided on an “as is” and “as available” basis, without warranties of any kind, whether express or implied, including as to accuracy, availability, or fitness for a particular purpose. We do not warrant that listings, prices, or descriptions are error-free.

15. Limitation of liability

To the fullest extent permitted by law, BookResorts will not be liable for any indirect, incidental, special, punitive, or consequential damages arising out of or connected with your use of the site or any booking. If we are found liable, our total liability will not exceed the greater of (a) the fees you paid to BookResorts for the booking at issue, or (b) US$100. This limitation reflects the allocation of risk between us.

16. Dispute resolution

We want to resolve any concern quickly and fairly. Before pursuing a formal claim, you agree to first contact our support team at 888-605-1350 or support@bookresorts.com and give us 60 days to resolve the matter informally. If we are unable to resolve it, any dispute will be handled by the state or federal courts located in California, as set out in Section 17 (either party may still bring qualifying claims in small claims court).

17. Governing law & venue

These Terms are governed by the laws of the State of California, USA, without regard to conflict-of-laws rules. Any permitted court action will be brought exclusively in the state or federal courts located in Los Angeles County, California, and you consent to their jurisdiction.

18. Changes to these terms

We may update these Terms from time to time. The version in effect at the time of your booking applies to that booking. Your continued use of the site after changes take effect means you accept the updated Terms.

19. Force majeure

We are not responsible for any failure or delay caused by events beyond our reasonable control, including severe weather, natural disasters, pandemics, strikes, government actions, or Supplier closures.

20. Miscellaneous

If any provision is found unenforceable, the remaining provisions stay in effect. Our failure to enforce a provision is not a waiver. These Terms are the entire agreement between you and us regarding the site.

21. Contact

Questions about these Terms or a reservation? Call our support team, available 24/7, at 888-605-1350.
Legal

Privacy Policy

Last updated: January 1, 2026

This Privacy Policy explains how BookResorts collects, uses, shares, and protects your personal information when you use our site or make a booking. For the purposes of applicable data protection law, the data controller is SVH Tours & Travel Services, Inc. (operating as BookResorts).

1. Information you provide

When you search, book, or contact us, we collect information such as your name, email, phone number, billing and payment details, the names and details of other guests, your travel dates and preferences, and the content of your communications with us.

2. Information we collect automatically

When you use the site, we automatically collect technical and usage data such as your device and browser type, IP address, approximate location, pages viewed, referring URLs, and interactions with the site, using cookies and similar technologies.

3. Information from other sources

We may receive information about you from Suppliers, business partners, fraud-prevention services, and (if you choose to connect one) social media platforms.

4. How we use your information

We use your information to process and manage bookings; communicate with you about reservations; provide customer support; personalize your experience; send marketing where permitted (with the ability to opt out); analyze and improve the site; prevent fraud and secure our services; and comply with legal obligations.

5. How we share your information

To complete a booking, we share necessary details with the relevant hotel and room Suppliers and with payment processors. We may also share information with service providers who support our operations, with advertising and analytics partners, with our corporate affiliates, in connection with a business transfer, with authorities where required by law, and with your consent.

6. Cookies & tracking

We use essential, performance, functional, and advertising cookies and similar technologies. You can manage non-essential cookies through your browser and through our cookie settings. For more detail, see our Cookie Policy.

7. Your privacy rights

Depending on where you live, you may have the right to access, correct, delete, or restrict the use of your personal information, to data portability, and to opt out of marketing.

EEA/UK (GDPR): You may access, rectify, erase, restrict, or object to processing of your data, withdraw consent, and lodge a complaint with your local supervisory authority. We process data based on your consent, the performance of a contract, our legitimate interests, and legal obligations.

California (CCPA/CPRA): You may request to know, delete, or correct your personal information, and limit the use of sensitive personal information, without discrimination. We do not sell or share your personal information as those terms are defined under California law, so no opt-out is necessary. To exercise any of your rights, contact us at support@bookresorts.com; we verify requests before responding.

8. Data retention

We keep personal information for as long as needed to provide our services and to meet legal, tax, accounting, and dispute-resolution obligations.

9. Security

We use reasonable technical and organizational measures to protect your information. However, no method of transmission or storage is completely secure, and we cannot guarantee absolute security.

10. International transfers

Your information may be processed in countries other than where you live. Where required, we put appropriate safeguards in place (such as standard contractual clauses) for those transfers.

11. Children’s privacy

The site is intended for adults and is not directed to children. We do not knowingly collect personal information from children under 18 without appropriate consent.

12. Third-party links & social features

The site may contain links to, or features from, third-party services. We are not responsible for the privacy practices of those third parties; please review their policies.

13. Changes to this policy

We may update this policy from time to time. The “last updated” date above reflects the current version, and we will provide notice of material changes where required.

14. Contact us

Questions or privacy requests? Reach our support team, available 24/7, at 888-605-1350 or by email at support@bookresorts.com.
About BookResorts · Independent since 1993

A better way to book your hotel

BookResorts is a full-service, independent travel agency connecting travelers to unforgettable stays since 1993. Detailed hotel information, competitive all-in rates and 24/7 concierge support, all in one place.

Est. 199330+ years
100K+Hotels & resorts
200+Countries
24/7Concierge
This is not the official website of Amara Cay Resort. BookResorts is an independent travel agency and is not owned by, affiliated with, endorsed by or sponsored by Amara Cay Resort or its parent brand.

Why travelers choose BookResorts

Best available rates

We compare rates from top suppliers. Taxes and fees included, no hidden charges.

100,000+ hotels & resorts

200+ countries and 2,000+ cities, from all-inclusives to boutique stays.

24/7 concierge

Real travel specialists to build, change or help with your reservation anytime.

Full transparency

Honest details on every property: rooms, amenities and policies.

Trusted since 1993

Three decades as a full-service, independent travel agency.

Secure & protected

Every booking is handled securely and your information is protected.

How booking with us works

Questions about a reservation? Our team is here 24/7 at 888-605-1350.
Full details in our Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy.

Lowest Price + Free Perks

UsOthers
Nightly rate
Price guarantee✓
No hidden fees✓
Perks & upgrades✓
24/7 concierge✓
Check availability

vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·

Book by phone888-605-1350
Book nowLowest rates Call usAvailable 24/7
Photo viewer